Response To: A Question of Character

Over break, one of my college friends tweeted me this link to a snippet from an interview with Daniel Handler, aka Lemony Snicket, regarding character and likability in literature. Go ahead and click over and read it. It’s short. And it should open in a new tab so you can easily come back when you are finished.

If you were too lazy to click over, basically Handler is ranting that a character need not be likable in fiction. Here’s the short version: “Characters are in books; you’re not going to have lunch with them. Moreover, the best books are full of trouble, so the characters are either in trouble or causing it. Most people aren’t likable in such situations.” And I think we can all agree that Count Olaf was as despicable as villain as there ever was. Now the short segment of the interview with Handler doesn’t make clear whether he is talking about some characters, all characters, heroes, or villains,  or if a character needs to be likable at all times in order to be deemed “likable.” But having read 10 of the 13 books in the Series of Unfortunate Events, I would argue that his three young Baudelaires were quite likable. Troubled, yes. Faulted, yes. Unfortunate,  yes. But all remained moral during their kerfuffles with the Count. So while Handler may say that likability doesn’t matter, he still achieves it — at least in the main characters in the works I have read.

And so as a young adult author, I will choose to do as he does and not as he says. And as a reader, I will seek books with a cool-sounding plot or a fantastic cover because I’m betting I’m going to find a likable main character. A hero may be ugly on many levels, but I’ll bet he or she will also be someone hopeful. Someone somehow special. Someone who I like to watch figure things out. In fact, I’m not sure I can name a book with a unlikable main character that did not in some way become redeemed. I CAN name quite a few who started off as a complete bitch, but then turned around. Those aren’t my favorite books, but I’d still call a character who has a whisper of a hope for humanity, and changes for the better, a generally likable character, simply because there is SOMETHING to like. I believe we as readers are constantly and fervently looking for that as we go along our bookish ways –that we have high threshold for pain — that we are forgiving of obstacles, flaws, and unfortunate events. Especially if we readers are children.

Published by jody sparks

Jody Sparks Mugele spent her first career in marketing writing and leading teams of writers and editors. After her son came out as transgender in 2015, she dedicated herself to advocating for the rights of the LGBTQ+ community. For two years, she led the Indianapolis regional chapter of PFLAG, a nationally renowned LGBTQ+ advocacy group. She has given many conference talks about parenting trans kids, healthcare in the trans community, and suicidality among LGBTQ+ youth. And with GenderNexus, an Indianapolis-based advocacy organization, she created programming and led support groups to work with parents to help their children through all aspects of gender transition. She recently moved to Northeast Georgia where she is excited to develop opportunities to continue to strongly and proudly advocate for LGBTQ+ members of our society. She also LOVES kitschy Christmas crafting!

One thought on “Response To: A Question of Character

  1. Yeah, I’m with you. I don’t know that I agree with him as to the main character. I think the main character should be flawed and grow but I don’t want to read a book about a main character that I really don’t like and don’t see much I can relate to in the early parts of the story. Maybe being somewhat unlikeable with things about the character we can relate to might work. But just like I don’t want to go to lunch with someone I don’t like, I don’t want to invest my time in a book about a character I can’t like and/or sympathize with on some level.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s